Attack of the Science Rakshaks – II : Indian Liberalism is trying to take over science

This is a continuation of yesterday’s post.

Infusing science with anti-semitism

Looking at the  “Appeal by Scientists” here  on the website of the Breakthrough Science Society that is organizing the march, a telltale fact that emerges is that one of the “scientists” making the appeal is JNU professor Ayesha Kidwai. It is a disturbing fact that Ms. Kidwai is involved with the “Indian Campaign for Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel”.


Those who want to slice up and divide knowledge (including scientific knowledge) based on the race, gender or nationality of who finds that knowledge cannot be seen as anything but enemies of science.

Does a scientific fact become less true if an Israeli person were to discover it? Should such a truth be boycotted? Is it not a foolish endeavor to try to boycott truth? How is this compatible with the spirit of scientific inquiry?

What kind of “scientist” would refuse to engage with a scientific idea because it came from someone in Israel?

Additionally, it must be noted that Ms. Ayesha Kidwai is not even a scientist (see official JNU profile here), but is still included in the list of “scientists” making the appeal. The only possibility that remains is that Ms. Kidwai has been included for purely political reasons, making the motives of the “March for Science” absolutely clear.

It should also be noted that passing off non-scientists in the disguise of scientists is standard operating procedure of  pseudo-scientific and anti-scientific initiatives.

Selective outrage

In keeping with the Left’s agenda of colonizing science, there has been a concerted effort to give widely publicity to superstitious / unscientific views expressed by members of the ruling BJP and its wider ideological parivar. As seen in the case of Pythagoras’ Theorem, the eagerness to drive this agenda has often overshadowed basic fact checking. However, the left generally stays silent when it comes to supporting real science on the ground … such as the time they could have come out and supported the BJP government in Maharashtra in requiring Madrasas to teach Math & Science. But they didn’t. Because votes. Minor children missing out on a chance to learn science be damned.

The left wing’s love for science appears to exist only at the media propaganda level. For instance, Prime Minister Modi’s remarks on Ganesha and plastic surgery have been magnified into some kind of legendary anti-science statement. Leaving aside the established fact that plastic surgery may well have existed in ancient India (as grudgingly conceded later by some liberals), the fact is that political parties and politicians engaging with unscientific thinking is not new.

In early 2013, Shashi Tharoor had launched the “Tiranga bangle” along with fellow Congress MP Navin Jindal.


The “Tiranga bangle” claimed to work wonders for treating everything from arthritis to gout to carpal tunnel syndrome. In keeping with the noblest traditions of pseudo-science, little was disclosed about the scientific mechanism behind the “miracle bangle”, except informing us that it had been designed with “tri-vortex technology from South Africa”. At that time, Shashi Tharoor was even MoS for Human Resource Development, but his participation in propagating pseudo-science did not become an issue.

One could go on and give several other examples, but the grand daddy of unscientific remarks by top Indian politicians would be Pandit Nehru saying that the whole world sleeps at the stroke of the midnight hour in India instead of realizing that many parts of the world experience broad daylight when it is night over here! Again, Pandit Nehru’s famous words are often read with pride, with no admission of the astonishing scientific error contained therein.

When it comes to the Left parties, the situation is even more grim. Based on their reading of Marx, the Communists have long opposed the Big Bang theory, which is the prevailing, well accepted cosmological model for the universe (see here). Here is the official website of the CPI(M)


The “so called Big Bang Theory” an “idealistic and creationist view of the world”? Calling on the “working class” to defend Marxist thinking by proving that black holes do not exist?

This sounds like an extract from the Mad Hatter talking in Alice in Wonderland, but unfortunately this stuff is coming from the website of the CPI(M). Ironically, the same CPI(M) often claims to take the lead in protecting “scientific temper” and the so called Science Rakshaks in the media and intelligentsia generally have little to say about the Communist war on science.

Now, I don’t know if Marx ever said that the Big Bang theory is wrong. Even if he did, it wouldn’t matter because he was not a physicist. But like any religious fundamentalist, the Communist takes a Boko Haram like approach to science, rejecting outright any idea that in his imagination appears to contradict something in his holy book. And calls upon the working class (i.e., the faithful) to defend their faith.

For those interested (and amused) by the silliness of asking the working class to fight black holes, the abstract of this paper written by a historian of science at Aarhus University in Denmark describes lucidly why Communists went nuts opposing the big bang theory.


Maligning the scientific method and individual scientists 

Being the current Vice Chancellor of JNU, Prof. M Jagadesh Kumar (who is also a professor of Electrical Engineering at IIT Delhi) is one of the prime targets for the liberal left. This hilarious hit piece which appeared in the DailyO makes a desperate effort to malign his character.


What? Prof. M Jagadesh Kumar boasts on his blog about lying to his students? What is the author talking about? I guess we are supposed to take the accuser seriously because it happens to be Ashok Swain, a professor of Peace and Conflict Studies at Uppsala University in Sweden.

However, clicking on the link to Prof. M Jagadesh Kumar’s blog reveals this hitjob to be an example of shocking scientific illiteracy on the part of the liberal author who tried to malign him. Prof. Jagadesh Kumar was talking in the context of physical equations which often contain an approximation along with an error term. The word “lies” was just a cute term he was using to describe approximations and to emphasize their importance in science. Anyone who has taken high school calculus should be able to understand this concept.

However, in the world of left liberals, maligning individual scientists as well as scientific method is not an ethical concern when it comes to advancing a political agenda.

In earlier cases, we have seen that even the most eminent scientists haven’t been spared the sword of the liberal agenda. For instance, a 2002 article by Sagarika Ghose written at the time Dr. Kalam was nominated for President, claims to have discovered a connection between atomic scientists, Hindu chauvinism, sexism and even casteism. Other gems include the finding that “science is particularly compatible with religious fundamentalism” (you read that right!) and that Osama bin Laden becoming a terrorist may have something to do with his engineering background in college.

Is calculus a rape manual?

Since both science and liberalism are global in their outlook, it forces us to take a wider view to understand how the left has tried to impose its worldview of science.  Extreme examples include left wing animal rights groups going  to the extent of bombing homes of scientists who are accused of cruelty to anything from lab mice to insects. Often, these are scientists carrying out vital researches into boosting agricultural productivity or developing life saving medicines.  This University of California  scientist got his house firebombed for being cruel … to fruitflies!

On the other hand, the environmental lobby, a pet darling of the international left, has often provided a safe home to all kinds of anti-scientific thinking. Mixing science with politics, the 9/11 attacks were another situation when major elements of the left aggressively pushed for science denial. By the way, here is a video of youth icon Kanhaiyya Kumar pushing for 9/11 conspiracy theories on the basis of fake science documentaries he watched on Youtube :

This may be a bitter pill for leftists to swallow, but scientific truth once established leaves no scope for “dissent”, least of all for “counterarguments” based on politics. No Azaadi from truth. Sorry.

However, one of the most outrageous yet least reported forms of anti-science propaganda comes from within the feminist movement. Is it possible for the human mind to become so muddled by ideology that high school mathematics looks like it is related to rape? Please hear out top feminist thinker Sandra Harding explain how calculus can be seen as a “rape manual”.


For this and other brilliant insights, Ms. Sandra Harding received a coveted position at UCLA! Can you imagine how left wing intelligentsia would have reacted if someone associated with RSS had drawn a connection between mathematics and rape and was then legitimized with a professorship at a major Indian university?

Within the belly of feminism, there are several other such anti-scientific gems. For instance, did you know that Einstein’s E=mc^2 is a “sexed equation” (click here to find out why) ?


We have to understand the basic modus operandi of liberalism. It identifies a group of people and hijacks their narrative, claiming to speak for all of them. The target group is then put within the left ideological cage and any attempt to break free is met with harshest kind of intimidation. 

How did the women’s movement worldwide or Dalit politics in India get straitjacketed into a socialist, quasi-communist movement? Was Ambedkar a Communist? He vehemently was not! How come “Ambedkarite” today most commonly means someone with Communist leanings? Because liberalism imprisoned these movements in its ideological cage.

Science is not and cannot become a political party. Science cannot live in a cage. A left wing ideological “March for Science” denigrates science and the scientific method.

Finally, to non-scientist Ms. Ayesha Kidwai who is part of the “appeal by scientists” for this “March for Science”, I have this to say: You can boycott a scientific truth and/or bully others into boycotting a scientific truth because it may have been found by someone from Israel or wherever, but you won’t win. Because :

E pur si muove (And yet it moves)

It’s attributed to Galileo when he was coerced by the Church to officially take back his view that the Earth moves around the sun.


7 thoughts on “Attack of the Science Rakshaks – II : Indian Liberalism is trying to take over science

  1. I am surprised you haven’t added “Gender is a social construct” push of feminists and the outright denial of genetics playing a role in human behaviour and achievement.
    Also I don’t think we should criticise Nehru implying the earth is flat.People will say it is poetic liberty,and from there the conversation descends into what he meant.I think we should discuss actions rather than words.Words are often very empty.


      1. One of your best pieces so far, CW. Not just because of the research involved, but the way it has been presented as well.

        Now, if only we could get these type of “leftist outing” writeups published in mainstream newspapers on a regular basis, there would be hope that people could wake up to the sinister designs of the left before it is too late.

        Wished the post was longer. I know you said you had only finite time, but couldn’t you just divide it by zero or something and make more time ?


  2. The inclusion of the JNU sociology professor should make it clear to even amateurs (meaning non-readers of this blog) that this “March for Science” is actually a “March against Modi” event. Now that all the awards have been returned (and surreptitiously taken back) and all the media greats are nearing their well deserved jail terms, it was time to tap into the liberal “scientists”.

    The real “March for Science” will be to close down the sociology and arts departments in Universities that have science and technology departments. The over-aged sociology/arts scholars are good for only “bharat ki barbadi” marches, conducting beef festivals and increasing violence and goondaism on campuses.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Fantastic read. The Leftists can jump up and down, but the reality is, the tiniest community in the world, a Jewish community hogs Nobel Prizes in science subjects, be that Jews from Russia, Jews America, Jews from Europe or Jews from Israel.

    It is surprising that Leftists and Muslims constantly side with Ambedkar when he was staunch against both of those community. They use Ambedkar’s name to attack upper caste Hindus, but never mention how Ambedkar got that Brahmin surname.


  4. Yesterday, I got to see a pamphlet printed for publicity of this ‘March for Science’. Was dejected to observe that some professors from IISc have also joined the bandwagon. I wonder if they really know what really lies beneath.


    1. Some IISc professors live in an Ivory tower that shields them from the real world. A bunch of “professors” had protested the nuclear tests way back in 1998. Can anyone imagine living next door to Jehadi countries like Pakistan and China and not having a nuclear deterrent ? Well, these IISc professors could.IISc needs to send some of these professors to the LOC and see what our jawans go through. Maybe that will instill some sense in them.

      I used to wonder – What kind of education is it when a lowly educated jawan is prepared to lay down his life for Dharma to prevail and a highly educated IISc professor joins the leftist bandwagon. Till I understood – The jawan has been schooled in the rich culture of Hindustan. This is the real education. The IISc professor has been schooled in the poor culture of Marxism. Hence the mental poverty and indifference to the nation.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s