Stepchildren of history : Godhra carnage victims and the left liberal complex


These days, we hear a lot of heavy words like “post-truth”. Mostly from liberal concubines of the Congress party who had to crawl out of bed in 2014 to suddenly discover “dissent”. You might have also heard the term “whataboutism”, which is the crime of remembering anything that liberals want you to forget.

However, the problem with our political discourse is not that we remember too much, but that we remember too little.

This is an article about the victims of the Godhra carnage of Feb 27, 2002. You know, those stepchildren of Indian history. We all remember the basics of what happened to them : S-6 coach, Sabarmati express, Signal Falia and the horrific death of 59 human beings. But how often do we remember what the left liberal complex in 2002 and later with the help of UPA government, tried to do to them?

Do we remember how the left liberal complex tried to implicate the victims of the Godhra carnage in their own murders?


This was published in the Outlook. It’s supposed to be a “Report to the Nation” by an “independent fact finding mission”.

As many as 59 human beings perished in the fire on that fateful day in February 2002. The left liberal complex did not hesitate to spread rumors about these unfortunate victims. Some said they didn’t pay for tea, some said they had pulled a Muslim man’s beard, some even spread rumors that they were assaulting women.

59 human beings are burned to death and the liberal “fact finding mission” reports that some of them may have unpaid debts of Rs 5. Just FIVE rupees.  In the eyes of a liberal, that’s how cheap human life can get. You must be familiar with Mr. Kamal Mitra Chenoy, one of the members of this “independent fact finding mission”, who now appears in TV debates and newspaper columns giving lectures on the equality and justice.

Some of the lies spread about the victims were even more fantastic in nature, appearing to defy even physical notions of time and space.  Here is Arundhati Roy explaining that the kar sevaks in 2002 were on their way back from demolishing the Babri Masjid in 1992!

Anything… absolutely anything to tarnish the unfortunate victims.

No liberal went to interview the family members of the Godhra victims. No liberal “fact finding mission” wanted to know who these people were and what were their hopes, dreams and aspirations that were burned inside the S-6 coach on Feb 27, 2002. Did anyone want to tell their stories and know them as fathers, daughters, mothers and husbands?

No, that dignity and courtesy is extended only to Kashmiri stone pelters shot by security forces, Lashkar operatives like Ishrat Jahan, dreaded criminals like Sohrabuddin and shockingly even Osama bin Laden!

Instead, the inconvenient victims of Godhra were supposed to be lumped into a corner and forgotten. Almost literally, because there was even a lot of liberal heartburn over an allegation that some of the dead bodies had been displayed in Ahmedabad. I don’t know if this actually happened, but so what if it did? Why is it so important to liberals that these victims be denied their one last chance to rock the conscience of the nation? Will the liberals who later took selfies outside Akhlaque’s house in Dadri let me know?

Then 2004 happened. Under UPA rule began one of the most shameful chapters of Indian history, where the government got actively involved in the effort to deny justice to the victims of Godhra. Then Railway minister Lalu Yadav created a special “U C Banerjee Committee” to “investigate” the Godhra incident, the result of which was a foregone conclusion.


The last bits of humanity and decency were shredded when Lalu Yadav went ahead and waved copies of the Banerjee panel report at his election rallies in Bihar.


There was no uproar in the liberal press at this attempt to deny justice to Godhra carnage victims. No intellectual returned any award.  Perhaps they were waiting for BJP to come back to power to show their spirit of “dissent”. No eminent persons signed any open letters. Perhaps they were saving their energies to lobby for leniency to Yakub Memon years later.

And I can say with confidence that the U C Banerjee panel was malafide. I have the words of the Honorable Gujarat High Court to back me up. Yes, not only did the High Court find the Banerjee panel to be illegal, but it also said this:


Don’t forget to read the last sentence. The UPA did not withdraw in shame when their intentions were exposed by the High Court. The UPA was so determined to deny justice to Godhra victims that it actually went ahead and challenged the decision before a division bench. And so deeply compromised was our liberal intelligentsia that they did not fear a single voice of “dissent”.

In case you are wondering, this shameful appeal was finally withdrawn in Aug 2014 by the Central Government after Narendra Modi became Prime Minister.

But it never really mattered that the Banerjee panel was found to be illegal and malafide. The lie had been seeded and it was now left to the liberal establishment (both in India and abroad) to make sure that the lie lives on forever. Here’s the BBC.


Here is the New York Times in 2016, as many as 11 years after the UPA seeded the lie.


Of course, it will never matter that the courts actually convicted the accused in the Godhra carnage.


Didn’t you hear Arundhati Roy in the video above saying “the train caught fire ; nobody knows who set fire to the train“? That’s the way it is always going to be. This is what came out in the Hindustan Times on February 27, 2017.


Yes, they’ll go soft even on Osama bin Laden on his “death anniversary” and tell stories of him as a father and husband. But the Godhra carnage victims deserve nothing. They are to be forgotten at best and condemned at worst. Here is what they will get, as the HT article goes on.


Yes, the liberal complex has gotten more and more diabolical with its theories over the last 15 years.

Back in 2002, the theory was that the kar sevaks were responsible for their own deaths because they provoked Muslim vendors at the railway station. But this explanation left the liberal  argument vulnerable. It is difficult to sustain the case that 59 people deserve to be burned to death because someone didn’t pay Rs 5.

So, somewhere between 2005 and 2010, this theory was discarded in favor of the accidental fire theory patronized by the UPA government. The advantage of this theory is that there is no moral responsibility to fight for justice to the Godhra victims.

But the liberal establishment didn’t stop there. As you can see, the new theory in town is that the carnage was a “a classic agent provocateur operation that went out of hand”. This time the liberals not only get to deny justice to the Godhra victims, they actually get to put the blame on a whole new bunch of innocents from the political parivar they despise.

It’s called having your cake and eating it too.

We know what happens next. Hopefully, at least some of the death sentences of the Godhra accused will be confirmed by the Supreme Court at some point in the future. The mercy petitions will then come up before the Union Cabinet. That’s when the liberal ecosystem will reactivate and tell us touching stories of the lives of these convicts as devoted sons of headmasters, fathers and husbands.  Should any of these death sentences be carried out, some liberal newspaper will come up with a headline like “And they hanged … “.

As you can see, there is more humiliation in store for the Godhra victims. I  am reconciled to this truth. I have only one little appeal for our ecosystem of eminent liberals : now that you have decided that the fire was an accident or a conspiracy by the right wing, you no longer need to create a justification for the actions of any Muslim mob. That means you no longer need to smear the long dead victims with the accusation that they didn’t pay Rs 5, which made them responsible for their own deaths. So, why don’t you let this one rumor go? See if you can find it in your hearts…


7 thoughts on “Stepchildren of history : Godhra carnage victims and the left liberal complex

  1. Indians hell bent on disintegrating the country. I dont think we should call communists liberals, their mindset is not to allow all sorts of thinking to prevail. True liberals fight for everyone’s rights and in this case all those effected by gujarat incidents. They should have fought for families of sevaks burnt. They are just politically driven propagandists. I am nationalist liberal and secular because of simple rule all those born here are indians and hindutava believes in allowing everyone to live in their own way. Period.


    1. For sure. I basically follow the same principles. What has happened is that the word liberal became so poisonous that even a right winger like me uses “liberal” uses as an insult… even though I would call myself liberal, nationalist and secular.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This all theories even after it was well established how the Muslims accumulated liters of petrol days ahead of planned attack. It has been well established, when the petrol was acquired, where it was stored, when and where the attack planning was done by the Godhra Muslims.

    Not only these 59 Kar Sevaks, reading our Presstitute media reports, how many of us know about some more than 340 Hindus killed in that 2002 racial riots? Have we ever heard about them or their families?

    These liberals are bleeding hearts when it came to Nirbhaya murder culprits, but want very badly death sentence to Bano’s murders even though, murders committed during a riots are never considered pre-meditated. Can you imagine what would have happened if the under 18 years culprit was included in the punishment?


    1. You know since 2002, I don’t think I have read a single article in mainstream media anywhere demanding “justice” for the karsewaks in Godhra. Only read about justice for Best Bakery, Gulberg society etc. I am happy at anybody getting justice, whether Hindu or Muslim, but when justice is not equal, it becomes a sentence.


  3. Wow! What a post, simply fantastic! Mazaa aa gayaa!

    And yes, to liberals – you say whatever you want to – NOBODY GIVES A FUCK NOW!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s