Has Saba Naqvi just suggested that Akhilesh Yadav deliberately lied on EVMs?

By now, the right wing is all too familiar with the continual left wing whining at The Wire. There’s really the same old cabal of usual suspects raising the same old talking points over and over again across the entire gamut of left wing propaganda websites : Scroll, Wire, Catchnews… you know the list.

Therefore at first glance, the recent article “The Opposition’s Guide to the BJP” published here in The Wire might seem entirely routine. It’s written by Saba Naqvi, one of the usual suspects. I like to refer to them as “history-sheeters of secularism”.

But there is one very interesting, very juicy tidbit that Ms. Naqvi lets us know in this article.


Interesting! Very very interesting! Let’s dissect what Saba Naqvi has said here.

(1) It seems that Saba Naqvi is telling us that at least one pollster who worked for Akhilesh Yadav had predicted a BJP landslide.

(2) Saba does not give precise information about exactly when the surveys were conducted, but she says that “he kept predicting a BJP wave”. This suggests there was more than one survey and those surveys all pointed to the same result.

(3) Saba tells us that “as the elections began, he polled 96 seats … and again threw up a BJP landslide”. The key parts of that sentence are “as the elections began” (which gives us a rough timeline for when the survey was done) and “again threw up a BJP landslide” (which tells us that the predicted BJP landslide tied up with previous findings).

(4) Saba mentions that at least one survey involved 1000 people each in 96 seats. That’s a total sample of 96000, which means this was a fairly expensive and detailed survey.

This is why Saba Naqvi concludes that “it is possible that Akhilesh acted with better information than Mayawati did“.

Why is this so interesting? Because, if there really was a pollster working for Akhilesh who had repeatedly predicted a BJP landslide in multiple surveys, where does this leave Mr. Akhilesh Yadav’s public positioning with respect to EVMs?


If the result on March 11 from Uttar Pradesh was on the same lines as the feedback that Akhilesh Yadav had received internally, why was there an effort to muddy the waters over EVMs? Was it a deliberate lie?

We have always known instinctively that questioning EVMs is the gambit of a sore loser. But this is the first time, we seem to have some direct evidence that a loser might be lying deliberately.

Of course, I have no independent way to verify whether Akhilesh Yadav was deliberately lying. For that matter, I have no way to independently verify whether Saba Naqvi is telling the truth, or what she knows or doesn’t know regarding this matter.  But from reading Ms. Saba Naqvi’s little revelation in The Wire, we certainly are entitled to the suspicion.

The election process is the cornerstone of our democracy.  It is now up to the journalistic ethics of Ms. Saba Naqvi to come out and clear the air. A deliberate effort to undermine public faith in the process is a very serious matter. If Ms. Saba Naqvi is in possession of information that will definitively expose the lie of someone trying to undermine faith in our elections, she should come forward and disclose it as an act of public service in the highest national interest.


5 thoughts on “Has Saba Naqvi just suggested that Akhilesh Yadav deliberately lied on EVMs?

  1. Will there be any action from our spineless government on the author of article in The Wire to force her to share the truth. Why we always expect individuals to do everything. Doesn’t the government have no means of forcing this issue given this disclosure. Please read the latest article in Mediacrooks.com. Very hard hitting. Truth really hurts. It looks like Government wants to keep focussing on elections and consequently no action, 5 years will pass by. They might still win 2019 but it would not be for their efforts but because of lack of opposition. President elections would be the next focus and more chest thumping will happen. Disappointed Modi Supporter


  2. M very surprised if Akhilesh was loosing then why all MSM was gaga over UP ke Ladke and projecting news like UP ke LADKE is Winning Election… Its shame on this Dishonest MSM of India…


  3. Ummm, I see two things here:

    1. Probably this was inserted on Akhilesh’s instruction to create a fighter’s image (for Akhilesh).
    2. We know that Ms. Naqvi is a chronic …… (you fill in with the word you deem appropriate). Given that history, should we actually believe in what she’s ranting about?


  4. Well, even if Akhilesh was sure that BJP will win big, can he or any seasoned politician expected to give up? After all there are many voters supported him. Even for them he has to show them that it was not his fault. Perhaps that is why he joined with Mayawati in claiming it must be EVM’s fault. The EC has challenged them and anybody else to prove that EVMs can be hacked. Mayawati, Akhilesh, Kejriwal all are hiding under the bed. Nobody has taken up the challenge.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s