Telangana CM is on to something and BJP should worry

This might actually be the first time I am explicitly devoting a blog post to the politics of Telangana. But I have been watching KCR’s politics with some fascination for a while. I know there are a lot of people who think that KCR has created an opening for BJP with his 12% reservation to Muslims. Maybe he has. But, in a larger scheme of things, I think KCR has hit on something big … and BJP should worry. It’s not as straightforward as some people seem to believe.

Hear me out. The politics of BJP has, thus far, benefited tremendously from Hindu resentment against the appeasement of Muslims. The Congress party and its northern clones such as RJD or SP have, generally speaking, walked into the trap. As the BJP kept increasing its influence, these parties walked a very straight and narrow path of brazen Muslim appeasement. You know… just taking things from Hindus and giving it to Muslims. The Congress, for its part, has come out openly in support of anti-nationals, jihadi terrorists, Naxals, even Pakistan…

No wonder they got clobbered in the elections.

But no! KCR’s 12% quota for Muslims is NOT in the same category. It’s just as brazen, but so what? KCR is carrying out a fascinating experiment of “double appeasement“.

What does that mean? Well, he is not just appeasing Muslims, he is appeasing Hindus too! His quota for Muslims was brazen, but then so were his massive gifts to Tirupati temple! He held Hindu yagyas with all the pomp and show of a grand Gupta Emperor.

Is it possible? Politicians of the Hindi belt have so far believed that you can only appease one at a time. Either Hindus or Muslims. KCR is breaking those rules and doing it in style.

And BJP should worry. If KCR’s new formula of “double appeasement” takes off … and I feel it is certainly succeeding in Telangana, BJP will have to go back to the drawing board for a new strategy. This strategy could very well spread among the states on India’s east coast that the BJP is eyeing greedily. And the Hindi belt politicians, including the Congress, might begin to learn.

Honestly, I am fascinated. I really didn’t think it was possible to appease both Hindus and Muslims at the same time. But that’s why politics is politics. And that’s why I have always seen politicians as geniuses… it really takes a lot to get millions of people to worship you… most politicians have a tremendous IQ ( be it even Laloo or Kejriwal ) and I am always in awe of them.  Surviving in politics is one of the hardest things a person can do and those who rise to the top like KCR or Modi or Nitish or Mulayam have to be special (dynasts obviously are excluded from this).

Further, I think KCR’s strategy has roots in what Mamata Banerjee has done in Bengal. On social media, we talk a lot about Mamata’s Muslim appeasement. It’s a real thing and the anger against this appeasement in the streets of Bengal is also very real. But let me tell you that it’s not as straightforward as people think. If you really look into the nitty gritties, Mamata Banerjee has done appeasement of several local Hindu sects at the micro level. You would be surprised at how Mamata has pulled out obscure Hindu festivals in Bengal and given them state patronage.

On the one hand, the “Hindi belt influence” is spreading like wildfire in Bengal. The recent observance of Ram Navami by the RSS/BJP was wildly successful. I was surprised at Bengali relatives wishing me a “Happy Shri Ramnavmi”. I nearly burst out laughing. Believe me, they wouldn’t have heard of Ramnavmi until 2-3 years ago. Now they don’t just celebrate it,  they also reverentially call it “Shri Ramnavmi” in full. The desire to appear like “real sanskritised Hindus” of Uttar Pradesh is very real. Naturally a good thing for BJP.

But there is a natural cap to the level of support that the BJP is getting. A large number of left leaning Bengali Hindus find a much greater level of comfort with Didi’s local, purely Bengali flavored Hinduism. Add it to the rock solid support of Muslims and she might have an electoral majority that could last a really long time.

Right now, there is a lot of exhileration among the RW over the BJP’s skyrocketing voteshares in Bengal. But remember, this is mostly happening because the BJP started from zero. Actually winning seats in Bengal could be a long way off. The BJP could get stuck at the 35% mark for a long long time. Remember that Congress also polls 40% of the votes in Gujarat. It’s just been sitting there, because the BJP is always 10% ahead of them. A respectable vote share does not guarantee power in the near future, not even a respectable seat tally.

The BJP  would be well advised to examine and re-evaluate the strategy on the East Coast. The regional satraps have created a new formula that could stop the BJP right in its tracks. Your move Amit Shah.



10 thoughts on “Telangana CM is on to something and BJP should worry

  1. We have a master in double appeasement, and that is none other than our PM Modi !!! He was fairly successful in uniting various castes of Hindus, and next he will try to unit the various religions of India. Triple Talak, Ujwala, Universal Basic Income all aimed at Sabka Sath Sabka Vikas, which is nothing but not double but treble appeasement !!!


  2. Do you think that Rs. 5 crores to the Tirupati temple is a HUGE gift? Please think again. No one believes that KCR is “appeasing” Hindus! The BJP in Telangana is led by a few useless local leaders who lobbied their clueless central leadership to permit the bifurcation of the state. So right now KCR is ruling supreme. What fascinates me about Telangana is that KCR’s son KTR actually appears to be more competent than Dad, a far cry from the usual situation in dynastic politics. THAT is what should worry the BJP!


    1. I agreed.The fact is that KCR is open hindu and regularly does Puja,follows vastu shastra and gives money to temples.But that is just token appeasement,not actual one.The equivalent of wearing muslim topi or offering namaaz or such stuff.
      The 12% reservation is actual appeasement in very divisive terms.He cannot appease everyone.It is bound to backfire,forget someone else following this formula.

      And about WB,this may seem bad but i think mamata is digging her own grave.slowly but steadily we keep hearing reports of communal violence there.Even the Ram Navami celebrations resulted in religious clashes.The situation is bound to deteriorate as the fanatic muslims can be trusted to be fanatics.And the BJP will slowly get serious in Bengal,which it was not because of the deal made to get GST passed.BJP unit is slowly and steadily being cleansed,as can be seen by the arrests of unscrupulous elements in it.And i can see the Centre gearing up and raiding her corrupt family members and politician chamcha,as she did with the mafia in TN


    2. Prof. Vidyasagar, first of all I think Hindus are quite easily satiated compared to Muslims. KCR’s expansive yagyas have sent a strong message. Secondly, the 12% reservation for Muslims is a non-gift, because courts are bound to strike it down. So, it is little more than a symbolic gesture. And I think Muslims know well that it won’t hold up in court. I remember YSR also tried to give 5% quota to Muslims and courts struck it down. Religion based reservation is clearly illegal in India. Law and precedents are both very clear on this. No chance of holding up in court.


  3. More than likely, this twelve percent Muslim quota will be declared unconstitutional soon. But in so doing, that is trying a staggering 62 percent reservation, should anger a lots of Hindu voting public in Telengana.

    BJP should find some ingenious way to show that those parties which engage in Muslim appeasement has just taken advantage of Muslims and done nothing for them.

    I have a relative in Ahmedavad who was telling me that before UP election, Modi/Shah made a special arrangement and every week some two bus loads of Muslims from UP were brought up to Ahmedavad so they can talk to the Muslims of Gujarat who are happy under Modi/BJP. This I did not read anywhere in the media.


    1. KCR is making many moves all at the same time. His Mission Bhagiratha (getting piped drinking water to every household), farm subsidies etc. are bound to get him reelected in 2019, he is unstoppable. The 12% reservation for the Peacefuls will fetch him their vote without taking away anything from the Hindu vote. People in the hinterland do not care much about such issues unfortunately.


  4. First article which i thought was resullt of not thorough analysis. Reservations cant be compared with one of pujas etc..not apple to apple comparison and write up sounds less researched. Besides you are reducing elections to casteism and religious appeasement. You are not taking into account point like non- corrupt government, bold decision making, intent to give good governance etc..


    1. You certainly could say that. I did write this article in a somewhat strange mood. But you have to take into account that Hindus are much easily appeased compared to Muslims. Further, remember that the 12% reservation for Muslims is little more than a joke, because the law is not worth the paper it is printed on. Obviously, the courts will throw out this 12% reservation. Law is very clear on banning reservation by religion.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s