Dear Swaminathan Aiyar, it is time to answer some tough questions on Rexit

Has anyone else noticed how a certain name has disappeared from the news cycle? No, I am not talking of names like M K Ganapathi, the police DSP of Karnataka who committed suicide last week leaving after blaming a certain honorable secular minister for his death. There are some names and some “institutional murders” that never make it to the news.

I am talking about Shri. Raghuram Rajan, the greatest economist, the greatest central banker, indeed the greatest human being to ever walk this planet. How did his name suddenly disappear from the news cycle after being in headlines for months?

Is it possible that reality did not cooperate with a certain class of elite analysts?? 

Let’s just pick one, particularly outspoken luminary called Mr. Swaminathan Aiyar. On June 22, writing in the Economic Times, a day before the Brexit referendum, Shri Aiyar made the following predictions in his article titled : “Rexit: This government has just shot itself in the foot“.



What did you say, Mister. Swaminathan Aiyar?  Portfolio investors could pull out billions of $$$ in the short term? Note that you said short term, no wiggle room there for you to claim that you were really suggesting that the impact will become visible 3 decades from now. No, my dear sir, you said short term.

And what else did you say on June 22, a day before the Brexit vote? That the “volatility could become a storm if Rexit is followed by Brexit?” Well, the pompously named “Rexit” was followed by Brexit. What is worse is that no opinion poll could predict the Brexit vote, which means the markets were shocked when the results came out. Perfect conditions for storm creation, don’t you think? Except, Mister Aiyar, where is the storm?

Here is the Sensex since your grand storm warning on June 22, 2016:


Up by close to a 1000 points since then…I pray that the Sensex be hit by many more such “storms”. Now it may go down again, but you said that it would be a reaction to Rexit. Well, Rexit was announced around June 18 and it’s July 12 already. We are approaching one month since the horrific news came and still global investors don’t seem to have heard about it. Did you know that cellphones transmit information at the speed of light, i.e. nearly 3 lakh kilometers a second?  Forget cellphones or the internet, thousands of people have flown back and forth from India on hundreds of flights to US, Europe and Japan since Rexit was announced. Surely someone must have told them about the Rexit tragedy in India? Are the global investors getting their news by pigeon courier these days, Mister Aiyar?  Even the pigeon couriers might have reached by now. When will the global investors find out about Rexit, Mister Aiyar?

Wait, there’s more. Here is Respected Mister Aiyar writing on June 5, 2016 in his article: “If Rajan exits, so will billions in investment



What? Did you say that the one thing you do know is that India will suffer a mass exodus of foreign portfolio investment if Rajan goes? Did you put seriously put the figure at as high as $100 billion? Did you say that the stock markets would crash and the currency markets will panic?

Show us! Yes, Mister Aiyar, show us that any of that actually happened… Oh and you said it yourself, the storm could get worse if it is accompanied by Brexit. Well, you got your nightmare scenario on Brexit. Now, show us the “panic in stock markets” and the $100 billion of outflows… Where is the exodus?

Ha ha, would you guys believe there is still more excrement that Swaminathan Aiyar has buried himself in? Here he is on June 9, 2016



Mister Aiyar, in case you have forgotten, the ISD code for dialling Singapore is +65. Try it, it really works 🙂 🙂 Call your friends in Singapore and cross check now..

But here is a further question. So you don’t deny that foreign investors and markets were in love with investing in India. I am not the one advancing that claim, your headline itself contains that implicit claim. Okay, well now that we have proved that it wasn’t Rajan that the markets were in love with…we have to answer this question:

So who was it that the global investors were ACTUALLY in love with? 

Go ahead. Answer that question 🙂 🙂  Let us hear you say the name 🙂

Could it be that the name of the person the investors were actually in love with starts with an “N” instead of an “R”? My guess is that this “N”  person must be Nayantara Sahgal, who kicked off the Award Wapsi campaign. What do you think, Mister Aiyar?

Ok friends, this is perhaps the most important part of this post:

Look, Mr. Swaminathan Aiyar, there is no shame when an honest prediction goes wrong. Every prediction contains an element of risk. Since nobody can predict the future with 100% certainty, do you know how we can tell a genuine analyst from a snake oil selling  propagandist? When a genuine analyst gets a prediction wrong, that person finds in her/himself the moral courage to stand up, step out and make a frank admission of error with due apologies to all. The snake oil selling propagandist goes silent and disappears into a hole hoping that people will forget about the giant mistake. Mr. Aiyar, you wrote passionately about how the markets would collapse if Rajan left. You wrote about it repeatedly; three times in your June 2016 columns: June 5, June 9 and June 22. Since your predictions went wrong, you have gone into a stony silence on this issue. You have published FOUR further blog posts on ET since June 22, 2016 but you have not made a frank admission of your mistake.  

So,  Mr. Swaminathan Aiyar, unless your next blog on ET boldly declares that you were massively wrong on the so called pompously named “Rexit”, you know *exactly*  what you are: genuine analyst or …

Listen, Mr. Swaminathan Aiyar, I know that we Modi Bhakts aren’t smart people. Few of us have doctorates in “South Asian studies” from JNU. I don’t know if anyone of us can explain what important words like “heteronormative” and “micro-aggression” mean. We know that we don’t usually ask intelligent questions such as : Is  GDP growth in India only helping the Hindu, heterosexual, upper caste males?  

But the fact remains that we got it right and you got it wrong on Raghuram Rajan. And if you feel that you are so high and mighty that you are above apologizing for blatant mistakes … 

Friends, please stay connected with this blog on the FB page:

16 thoughts on “Dear Swaminathan Aiyar, it is time to answer some tough questions on Rexit

  1. Swaninathan Aiyar is the brother of Mani Shankar Aiyar.Expecting an unbiased opinion from him is like expecting Muslims in Kashmir to vote for BJP.


  2. Monsoon session starting on Monday.NDA plans to put GST to vote on Monday itself.Article stated that Priyanka Gandhi wanted Congress to change its view on GST and pass it.Reality is that they know that because NDA’s numbers have increased,because of Cong’s losses in the May elections and because most parties support GST,if parties pass GST without Cong,it will dent their shredded image further so they want to take credit and say later that “this bill was passed only due to Priyanka Gandhi’s efforts” . I have a feeling that it will be passed in this session.


  3. My suggestion to Swaminathan Iyer- Proabably like your Idol, R3, please repeat every 15 days that because of Rexit and Brexit markets will collapse, trillions of Foreign Investments will fly away, and so on. One day, say in a decade or two, it will happen. Then for all leftists, intellectuals and other such crowd you will be the new idol.


  4. And the market went up by 600+ points in just the last two days itself. 🙂 Frankly, I didn’t have a problem with Rajan and wish he had stayed. The mistake he made (which is probably the reason he was not offered a second term) is that he got too big for his shoes and started making public his observations on polity. If the recent cabinet reshuffle has shown us anything, it is that silent achievers are more likely to be rewarded than those who go about chest-beating.


    1. Yes, didn’t have much of a problem with Rajan per se. But Rajan allowed Modi’s political opponents to build him up as a counter figure and he paid the price. Should have stuck to his job, instead of cow beef intolerance.


  5. Swaminathan Aiyar is no different from the random idiots who talk up and recommend stocks on the different finance TV channels. If the stock goes up, they will claim credit, if it goes down they will quietly recommend another stock. Once in a while, by pure chance they will be right.


    1. I suspect nearly 100% of TV talking heads fall into this category. Saw a study once that showed randomly investing is about as successful as listening to these experts. But Swami lost all balance, predicted $100 billion of losses…drank his own cool-aid.


  6. Mr. Aiyar’s prediction about the health of Financial Market is very close to Aakar Patel’s prediction about Narendra Modi’s political future. If your betting average is so poor in gambling, you would be history. This Aiyar got to write some more for ET shows the quality of ET itself.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s