Bihar

Well, I can’t imagine anything else being on my mind or the minds of my readers right now. Let me start by guessing what I think is gonna happen tomorrow.

BJP Strike Rate =60%   60% of 160 seats = 96

LJP strike rate = 40%     40% of 40 seats = 16

HAM strike rate = 33%    33% of 20 seats = 7

RLSP strike rate = 10%   10% of 20 seats = 2

Total for NDA = 121

I am no psephologist. I have never predicted numbers before. So I could be badly wrong. But I think these will be the strike rates, with the strong possibility that LJP and HAM’s strike rate could be higher than 40% and 33% respectively. LJP might touch 50% but not much more. However, with HAM, I have a feeling they might be the surprise package. They could go way above 33%.

There is a distinct possibility that RLSP might end up with a big fat ZERO.

With Today’s Chanakya, Cicero and Hansa predicting in our favor and Cvoter showing a narrow defeat by 1% vote share, I feel fairly confident of NDA’s win tomorrow. What adds to my confidence is the fact that Bihar is a state where BJP has routinely been underestimated by both pollsters and analysts. In 2005, no one saw that BJP would actually emerge larger than RJD. And most analysts were surprised at BJP’s 91/102 score in 2010. Most were predicting that Nitish’s JDU would sharply increase its seats, but BJP would prove a burden on its ally. Most were left speechless when the BJP swept 91/102 in 2010, with a strike rate that exceeded that of JDU.

Similarly, BJP was a victim of underestimation by analysts in 2013, when most were of the view that Nitish had delivered a masterstroke by snapping ties with the BJP. Even when the Modi wave hit shores in Apr-May 2014 and people realized that Nitish was a goner, there was chatter among analysts of a last minute Lalu surge.

There is a reason Lutyens loves Lalu so much, even though he is nothing like them. Lutyens sees in Lalu a confirmation of their view of ordinary desis: casteist, uncivilized, lawless and unable to govern. Like British colonial masters were fascinated by native jugglers performing The Great Indian Rope Trick, Lutyens derives great pleasure from Lalu’s antics. And because Lalu does not threaten the power of the Dynasty, it is a great sport for Lutyens to watch from a safe distance. This is why before every Bihar election, Lutyens indulges in wishful thinking about a Lalu revival.

My guess is that JDU is going to perform very well in it 100 seats tomorrow. But RJD and Cong will have a meltdown in their 140 seats, handing the NDA a victory. This is the “double wave” theory I had written about nearly a month ago. People want the BJP. And people want the JDU.  It was a good partnership that was doing genuine good to the people of the impoverished state. There can be no doubt that Nitish Kumar was a good Chief Minister. But he has sinned against the people by disrespecting their mandate and fallen prey to jealousy and ego. And for that, the people will punish him.

There are definitely some further considerations here. The BJP must be prepared for the post poll possibility of Manjhi being offered the CM chair by Nitish-Lalu, especially if HAM performs well. If NDA wins comfortably, it is of foremost importance that the BJP choose a strong Chief Minister for Bihar. Nitish was a good CM and will be a tough act to follow. If the new Bihar CM falls short of Nitish’s performance, the BJP will face complete disaster in Bihar in 2019. On the other hand, if the Mahathugbandhan wins, the BJP is assured of sweeping Bihar in 2019 because there is no way a rickety hodge-podge government of Nitish-Lalu can run the state effectively. In this respect, the BJP is in serious danger of winning the battle and losing the war tomorrow.

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “Bihar

  1. While results will be out in a couple of hrs. Could you list the ministries that BJP handled under Nitishwa. I hated Vajpayee for making this nobody CM at expense of his own party. Selfish fool.

    Like

    1. The biggest mistake Advani and Vajpayee made was that they thought BJP had reached saturation point under them. So they were ready to yield to people like Nitish Kumar. This is the big Modi difference. Modi and Shah want to win every panchayat.

      Like

  2. NDTV has been lying about their female journalist being heckled at Jawab Do protest. Check out the real (full) video behind the alleged heckling of NDTV journalist Bhairavi at Anupam Kher’s #MarchForIndia :

    The audio is clear and we can tell who instigated and no abuses were there. Only slogans calling it ‘Nehru Dynasty TV’ and ‘NDTV hai hai’.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. I beg to differ with you a little bit. I agree that Nitish Kumar was a good CM as long as he did not have extraneous issue on his mind. When he developed intense hatred towards Narendra Modi, He spent a substantial time trying to derail Mr. Modi’s march towards PM-ship. After the election, he chose a puppet CM (his poor judgement) and when that CM started to raise his head, he spent a lots of time planning to dethrone him (again poor judgement). After dethroning his puppet CM with dirty tricks, he got busy in building Mahagathbandhan (poor judgement). In another words, ever since he separated from NDA, he became very ordinary CM. Goes to show that jealousy and intense hatred towards somebody will rob you of your potential completely.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Indeed, things in Bihar fell apart from the time Nitish parted ways with the BJP. But unfortunately, sufficient time hasn’t passed since June 2013 for people of Bihar to realize the difference fully. Worse, Manjhi was CM for part of this period after June 2013 and he is with NDA now. So, Nitish is still being evaluated mostly on his pre-June 2013 record. If a Nitish-Lalu ramshackle government comes, it will be wiped out in 2019. But I don’t think the Mahathugbandhan is winning. We’ll find out in a couple of hours 🙂

      Like

  4. I can’t believe this. “Insha Alla” people have won Bihar!!! That man Prashant Kishore is something. Or people of Bihar just love Nitishwa and Lalu too much. Just fail to understand how Lalu’s party won 60+ seats! Unbelievable. Bihar continues to flummox us….! Worse still, BJP lost ground and percentage of winning nose dived as well. I see this as some clever work from Prashant Kishore. He was successful in taking the subject away from real issues. On the other hand some silver lining as you said, battle may be lsot but war will come in 2019.

    Like

  5. Bihar is over and NDA is in the opposition. Congratulations to Mahagatbandhan and to the people of Bihar. A silent introspection and a rigorously planned strategy for the future is called for by NDA if India has to prosper as a Nation. The forces of derision will be at their best and more virulently.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. @Somayajulu – You are right and you are dead right in your last sentence. Those forces have already started working. Read some twitter comments at niticentral on what Rajdeep and Dereck Obrian said after BJP loss. It is humiliating for India lovers to listen what they are saying in TV channels. It is time for BJP to take in the humiliation, absorb it and then plan well for the future.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s